Galit Na Naman Si Tita: SOBRANG KALAT

If you had told me that the month of May on bookish Twitter was going to end like this, I wouldn’t have believed you. I mean, sometimes I think the bar for authors to behave is literally on the fucking ground, but hoo boy, some of these people have got industrial shovels.

Let me preface this entry in the Galit Na Naman Si Tita series with the following premises:

  1. Unlike my previous entries where I was more disappointed or frustrated, this time, I actually am mad. I am steaming, boiling mad.
  2. ALL OF THIS COULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED IF PEOPLE LEARNED HOW TO MAKE PRIVATE LOCKED ACCOUNTS, IT IS NOT THAT HARD.

All right, let’s get started.

line-separator-green

I don’t particularly care to Sherlock Holmes this situation in as in-depth a manner as I possibly can (and honestly if you’ve been around Twitter in the past 72 hours, you probably have a vague idea of what went down), so here’s a quick summary. A bunch of YA authors started talking about how they shipped Jon Snow and Sansa Stark from Game of Thrones (who for those not in the know, they were raised as brother and sister and later on in the show discover they are actually cousins). This shipping included notable phrases like, “I DON’T CARE IF THEY’RE RELATED, THEY BELONG TOGETHER.” (Yes, really.) Naturally, these authors got called out. This somehow led to a whole bunch of YA authors defending their right to ship incest (which…uh…weird hill to die on, but okay) and also basically saying that there are no teenagers on Goodreads or Twitter, and even if they were, they wouldn’t care about authors shipping incest.

The morality and ethics of shipping incest (and wow, there’s a phrase I never thought I’d ever type) aside, there’s something about the all-around attitude of the YA authors involved in this brouhaha that immensely bothers me. A shit ton of them don’t actually care about their audience. After all, if they did, they wouldn’t be defending their right to post questionable content by saying patently untrue things like “there are no teens on Goodreads or Twitter” (which, what the fuck, a cursory search would have proven this false).

I’m not a YA book blogger. The books I read and feature on my blog run the gamut from adult to middle grade. Technically speaking, my target audience is not strictly teenagers. And yet, here’s the thing: I’m very careful about what I say and present as normal and acceptable anyway. Why? Because the sheer fact that I read and feature YA and MG books on my blog automatically means that I am going to have a YA and MG audience, and with that comes the innate responsibility of making sure that the content I provide is not harmful or toxic.

Yes, I said innate. Because producing content for the world to consume puts the onus on you, the creator, to make sure that content is safe for consumption. And that, Jesus good God almighty, includes the tweets you spew out onto that hellish website.

I talked about this a little bit in my post On Being a Critical Reader and Book Blogger. In that essay, I wrote how, the minute we position ourselves as book bloggers, whose opinions will be read by an audience that could possibly be influenced by them, we have a responsibility to be as informed and as aware as we possibly can, and to keep on learning and bettering ourselves. The same goes for authors – in particular YA and MG authors, precisely because their target audience is much, much younger.

I’ll repeat what I said in my post on responsible book blogging. No one put a gun to your head and forced you to become a YA author. You did that all on your own, and the minute that your book went out into a world where it would be read by teenagers and children, the minute you market yourself as a professional selling a product, you owe it to the audience who will consume your content to make sure that that content isn’t toxic or harmful or just plain gross.

In short? If you’re going to ship incest, at least make it clear that its an unacceptable thing IRL and admit that your ship is toxic and problematic and not the “oh, they’re so cute together, they have such good chemistry” bullshit y’all have been shoving in Twitter’s face.

Does that mean that you, as a person, are responsible for the value formation and role modeling of teenagers and of children? Of course not. You’re not their parents, after all. But I firmly believe that marketing yourself as a content provider for that particular age range demands a certain standard of behavior in public spaces. Twitter is one such public space; and not promoting and defending incest is one such standard of behavior.

This is why God invented incognito mode, DMs, and locked private accounts, praise His name. 🙄

Oh, and it goes without saying, but when literal goddamn minors publicly state that your behavior is making them uncomfortable? YOU CUT THAT SHIT OUT. NO IFS, ANDS, OR BUTS.

There are a ton of teen book bloggers, booktubers, and bookstagrammers who make this community a more enriching and rewarding place. They are not dumb. They are not ignorant. But at the same time, there are also things that they aren’t comfortable or ready to see or discuss. There are definitely things that shouldn’t be normalized or made to seem okay around them – or anyone, for that matter.

Here’s the best advice I can give to anyone producing content for a teen audience. LISTEN TO WHAT THEY HAVE TO SAY.

Because I guarantee, they’re listening to you as well.

Ya tita, out.

Love and light,

kate

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “Galit Na Naman Si Tita: SOBRANG KALAT

  1. Preach! Personally, I would’ve been okay with it had they admitted it was a toxic ship (well, I mean, I would’ve still thought it was really gross). But getting so defensive about shipping incest, claiming you’re being “shamed” for your “innocent shipping preferences”, saying “it’s okay because it’s fiction”, etc is just… a disaster. And as someone with two brothers, one of them who’s adopted, it really bothers me when people say “well, they’re not actually siblings because one of them is adopted”, like… wtf??? So if you adopt a child then it’s ok to have a relationship with them because they’re not actually your kid? What kind of Woody Allen bullshit is that? They should just admit their mistakes, learn and actually care about their public

    Liked by 1 person

    1. What kind of Woody Allen bullshit is that?

      *cackles*

      Personally, I would’ve been okay with it had they admitted it was a toxic ship (well, I mean, I would’ve still thought it was really gross). But getting so defensive about shipping incest, claiming you’re being “shamed” for your “innocent shipping preferences”, saying “it’s okay because it’s fiction”, etc is just… a disaster.

      YES. ABSOLUTELY THIS.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you so much for putting together such a thoughtful post on this whole situation, Kate. Grossness of shipping incest aside, I was extremely appalled by the lack of shits that a lot of authors have for their audiences.

    I have a lot of complicated feelings about cancelling someone for their ships (no, I don’t condone incest ever), but for the love of everything holy when someone tells you that your comments make them uncomfortable the human thing to do is APOLOGIZE. Not to double down that teenagers don’t exist on the internet and joke that they will lose only 4 sales because that is how large their teen readership is. It’s fucking gross, dismissive, and I refuse to give my hard earned money to the pockets of people that treat their fans in such a way.

    If they want to be able to spew whatever thought that crosses their mind, get a locked twitter account like every other logical person with a platform of influence.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. for the love of everything holy when someone tells you that your comments make them uncomfortable the human thing to do is APOLOGIZE

      YUP!!!!!!

      The grossest thing about this whole thing is it wasn’t just teens saying they were uncomfortable; it was teens who had been the victims of incestuous abuse saying that they were uncomfortable with public figures seemingly condoning it. I mean, how in the HECK are you gonna read that sentiment from a kid whose been hurt and still double down on your dickholery?????

      Like

  3. Thank you for writing such a thoughtful and great piece, Kate. Putting the incest stuff aside (who would’ve thought that would be something I would be saying…), I have a major issue with the way that authors, in particular YA authors, have been handling themselves on Twitter lately. It really feels like some authors treat it like a little Mean Girls club where they can be snippy and derogatory towards fans, and display unprofessional behaviour towards each other. Like yes, that’s your Twitter account, fine. But it’s also your PROFESSIONAL AUTHOR ACCOUNT??? I don’t get how so many people don’t understand that.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Honestly after this whole debacle, I refuse to feel guilty about anything I ship ever again. >.>

      But yes, you hit the nail on the head. Everything about this was just absolutely unprofessional. Considering that these people are essentially service-providers interacting with their clientele, who are minors? Gross on so many levels.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I still cannot believe this is a thing that happened and I was trying to stay well out of it but SUCH A WEIRD HILL TO DIE ON I MEAN???

    I love how eloquent your rant is, and how polite you still come across as because I would not be as polite if I vented.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Every day we stray further from decency, and the West is testing the boundaries of it. There’s an active normalization of incest and pedophilia (just look at Reddit) – and it’s bleeding out to books.

    Good thing the young’uns know better.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. My god, the YA community really does deserve its reputation of being a whole ass MESS. If YA authors aren’t bitching about bad reviews, they’re pulling stunts like this. Seriously, those authors deadass thought that they could ship incest without people getting weirded out – westerners are wild, I swear.
    Additionally, Edgelord A. Duncan continues to be the worst, no surprise there lol

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s